The Art of Asking by Amanda Palmer Examples in Real Life

"Information technology would be a terrible calamity," Henry Miller wrote in his meditation on the cute osmosis between giving and receiving, "for the earth if nosotros eliminated the beggar. The beggar is just as important in the scheme of things as the giver. If begging were ever eliminated God help us if there should no longer be a need to appeal to another human beingness, to make him give of his riches." And yet, we live in a culture that perpetuates the false perception of a sure power dynamic between giver and receiver, and — worse yet — stigmatizes the very act of request equally undignified.

Last week, I had the pleasure of spending some fourth dimension with the wonderful Amanda Palmer who, besides being an extraordinarily talented musician, is likewise a fellow champion of open culture and believer in making skillful piece of work freely available, trusting that those who discover value in it will support it accordingly. Disillusioned with the questionable success standards of the music manufacture, she recently left her record label and set up out to self-release her adjacent album in what became the most heartily funded music project in the history of Kickstarter — but not without some harsh criticism by those also attached to the aging comforts of the Olden Ways. In this brave talk, easily my favorite TED talk of all time, Amanda invites us to reclaim the art of asking from the insecure grip of shame and gloat information technology instead as the sublime surge of mutuality that it is:

Through the very deed of request people, I connected with them. And when you connect with them, people want to assist you. It'due south kind of counterintuitive for a lot of artists — they don't want to ask for things. It's non easy to ask. … Asking makes yous vulnerable.

[…]

I don't run across these things every bit risks — I run into them as trust. … But the perfect tools tin can't help us if we tin can't face each other, and give and receive fearlessly — merely, more chiefly, to ask without shame. … When we really come across each other, we want to assist each other. I remember people accept been obsessed with the wrong question, which is, 'How practice we make people pay for music?' What if we started asking, 'How practice nosotros let people pay for music?'

Given how close to home Amanda's eloquent words strike, I chatted with her about what seems to be the greatest challenge to this cultural shift toward destigmatizing asking:

MP: As someone who's been called an "internet pan-handler" for asking my customs for support, I'1000 astounded past some people'south cynicism in failing to see the dignified mutuality in these exchanges. What can nosotros do to shift the culture effectually them from pan-treatment to daisy-handing?

AP: Well…this is the problem with doing a 12-infinitesimal TED talk instead of writing a 220-page book. At that place'south a lot of simplification involved. The concept is more than or less that when you trust people to help you, they often do, and artists have done this from the dawn of fourth dimension. I'yard sure the early on-days minstrels were epically talented couchsurfers. Maybe there were cave-surfers mode back in the day, who knows.

I saw a comment on the TED website that basically said, "this model is bullshit… would yous experience OK if Justin Bieber decided to crowdsource teenage girls to be his maids and clean his room, etc.," and that got me thinking. First of all, it isn't most the theoretical, information technology's about what artists/people actually do. I doubtfulness Justin Bieber would think it was a wise idea to permit a giddy little fan into his pad and clean upwardly his stuff, information technology'd be a huge pain in this ass for him and his privacy, etc., since he's a celebrity and all he'd need is that 1 fan tweeting a pic of the joint and used condom by his bedside and he'd take a PR nightmare on his hands.

And the Bieber example is odd, because it involves children, but let's say the example was, I don't know, Ozzy Osbourne. Permit's say Ozzy puts out a telephone call for crowdsourced maids. If an adult raises his or her hand and says, "Hell aye!!! I'm happy to spend X time being Ozzy'southward maid, this'll be interesting," isn't that a off-white exchange between 2 consenting adults? Don't people do weird shit all the fourth dimension for each other, for costless, but for the experience? The story? The feeling?

What if we replaced Ozzy with … I don't know … the Dalai Llama? Would we estimate it differently? A lot of young monks give up their possessions, go study with a master, and do their master's dishes … and nosotros think of this in a kind of gentle-hearted karate-kid sort of romanticism. …

The idea is to let adults make their own rules, their own exchanges, their own decisions. Nosotros all value unlike things and experiences in different ways — and nosotros tin can get very creative nigh it, and about the means we help each other.

To partake in the architecture of this new paradigm and revel in the two-way street of this glorious mutuality, support Amanda's music and ethos on her site, where yous can download her fantastic new anthology — for gratis or for all the same much you'd like — and go meet i of her shows if you become a chance. For more of her spirit of fierce openness, follow her Twitter.

Photograph: James Duncan Davidson for TED

ayalabaced1986.blogspot.com

Source: https://www.themarginalian.org/2013/03/04/amanda-palmer-on-the-art-of-asking-ted/

Bagikan Artikel ini